Brett Bull speaks to an American gentleman who has spent more than 26 years sharpening his knowledge of the art of traditional sword polishing.
When Jon Bowhay picks up a Japanese sword, samurai fantasies of hacking at armor and crushing bone – probably standard visions for most – are not what come to mind. Rather, the sword’s overall condition, its design and its quality of craftsmanship, are his focus.
First, he’ll hold the sword by the handle in his palm, ensuring that he doesn’t actually touch the blade itself.
“I check to see if it is straight,” he says, tucking his right fist under his nose extending his left in front as he might if he were staring down the barrel of a gun. “I check for lumpiness and dips. I check to see if there are any flaws or forging problems to be careful of.”
Jon Bowhay is a Japanese sword polisher, or togishi. “Restorer,” though, is likely more appropriate wording since his work might require that he remove rust accumulated over hundreds of years, reshape edges to eliminate nicks or strip off steel to remove pits.
“As a polisher you have to make sure the (sword’s) cross section remains consistent to the original,” explains the 65 year-old, a bit of throwback in two-decade-old gray slacks and white cotton shirt adorned in a series of stitched filigree patterns. “You don’t want to just sharpen it. You want to return it to the original.”
For centuries Japanese swords were the trusty weapons of the samurai who wielded them. Today swords that possess ornate designs and fine craftsmanship can be seen as very valuable artifacts.
The job of the polisher is to give this art its due respect in the form of preservation. But the task is hard work that requires a 10-year apprenticeship and countless hours of working the steel blade over a stone in a hunched-over position. For the average polisher the physical grind is daunting enough, but for the foreigner who chooses to enter this field, seen solely as a Japanese art, the challenge is magnified much more.
In the first polishing step, known as shitaji, stones of varying degrees of coarseness remove rust and restore the blade to its original shape.
“You have to find the stone that works well with the proper sword,” Bowhay warns when asked about the importance of selecting the right stones, which can be as large a box of tissues and as small as a pinky fingernail. “If you don’t, you’ll get scratches.”
This determination requires an understanding of the period and smith school of the blade. The lay of the steel, the manner in which the steel has been worked or tempered and the curvature of the blade are all factors to consider.
The forging of a blade is not simple. Two different types of steel (roughly in the shape of a blade) are first hammered together. In a repetitive process that requires heat from a fire and sweat from the smith, the steel is folded over upon itself and then hammered back out to its original thickness and length. This folding gives the blade a layered composition. When this is finished a file is used to give the sword its shape.
“Any period of time you’ll find any shape,” Bowhay whose oldest sword he has worked on dated to the seventh century. “So you have to look at everything to decide the period of time. There are copies as well and they are legitimate copies. If a smith liked a particular style, he did it. You have to look at everything as an aggregate to determine the period.”
His work takes place at his polishing bench situated within the workshop within his home in Tokyo’s Nerima Ward. Here, a rubber strap holds the stones onto the bench’s wood frame. Holes cut into the wood on either side are for Bowhay’s legs. As he works, he sits and moves the blade over the stone.
This setup is an innovation on his part. Initially, like most togishi, he held the stone with his feet, resulting in a much more hunched position than this new arrangement. A hernia caused him to make the change.
The final polish gives the sword the renowned mirror-like finish along its back, non-cutting surfaces. This is due to burnishing with tapered, hard steel rods, the tips of which alone can cost ¥15,000.
“Even if you are careful, you can scratch the hell out of it,” Bowhay explains. “So have you have figure out what direction the steel is going in. It takes tactile skill; you have to mash the steel in one direction.”
Working 10 to 12 hours a day, the entire polish can take a couple weeks. A typical charge, including the polish, a new sheath and any adjustments needed to the handle, is roughly ¥400,000.
Since metal is being stripped off with each polish, a sword’s life depends on the damage and makeup. Time between polishes could range between 10 and 100 years, and often longer. It is hardly an exact science.
Though a sword’s principal function is combat, care is a key to increasing the length of time between polishes. For one, touching the blade is strictly prohibited, Bowhay advises. Otherwise, you will “spoil the steel.” Storage in a low humidity environment is necessary as well.
Born in the United States, Bowhay came to Japan with his family near the end of the occupation. He became interested in swords at an early age but he wasn’t able to get an apprenticeship until 1979.
At his peak, he made ¥8 million yen annually. Today business has fallen but he still polishes eight to 10 swords a year.
Love of art was his reason for entering this, as he describes, “arcane” field, likening the study of swords to the admiration of a painting. “To appreciate it,” Bowhay says, “you have to look at the brush strokes, you have to look at the coloring, the composition, everything, to see how it works. Swords are even more so, because they are so delicate.”
But there are hazards to this business. In addition to migraines, accidents will happen. Bowhay once dropped a sword. When he reached for it out of instinct, his thumb caught the cutting edge. “A piece of my thumb went bouncing across floor,” he remembers.
There is general frustration as well. Bowhay believes that the narrow definition of art in Japan has resulted in sword polishing being “very ethnocentric” and only open to the Japanese.
He feels that art is supposed to move the human spirit, the part that is difficult to express. Such expression is to lack ethnic boundaries; this isn’t true in Japan, Boway believes.
Acceptance of his work has been very difficult in spite of the fact that he is highly trained and greatly respected outside of Japan. As a result, nearly all of his customers are collectors in the United States.
“To be effectively made impotent in your own vocation with great intent is overly cruel,” he says of the general lack of appreciation he has received in Japan.
Even though he has been in Japan for a half-century, Bowhay, who has two adult children, sees himself eventually leaving. Colorado, where he is currently storing his custom-made, cream-colored 1979 Lincoln Mark V with blue crushed velvet interior, is a possible destination.
While today there are only a handful of non-Japanese togishi around the world, the aura of preserving swords, Bowhay feels, will allow the profession to continue to draw the interest of outsiders in the future.
Bowhay sees the romanticism of the samurai, whose spirit, it is often said, rested within his sword, as a powerful draw. “We all get off on romanticism,” he says.
3-17-33 Shimoochiai, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo
tel: 03-3951-3312; web: www.iidakoendo.com
In the business for over a century, this shop sells antique swords and armor. Feel free to bring in a family heirloom for an appraisal.
3-8-1 Toranomon, Minato-ku, Tokyo
tel: 03-3434-4321; web: www.japansword.co.jp
Swords and armor, both authentic and reproductions, have been available at this shop since the Meiji Period. Take a trip back to the days of the samurai at this shop but make sure your wallet is ready for today’s prices.
1-3-4 Kudanshita-kita, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo
Bring your bushido dreams to life here, safely. This shop is a specialist in dealing in iaito, or practice swords. The edges to the blades are blunt but the samurai spirit remains as sharp the warrior who wields it.
4-25-10 Yoyogi, Shibuya-ku, Tokyo
Short on cash but interested in getting a close look at modern and antique swords? Well, take a stroll between Shibuya and Shinjuku (with ¥500 in your pocket) and stop in this museum.
Story by Brett Bull
From J SELECT Magazine, May 2005